Lingayat label: Is religion connected to SC/ST quota benefits? Facts and myths



  1. Home 
  2. Opinion 
  3. Facts & myths of Lingayat label and SC/ST benefits


Facts & myths of Lingayat label and SC/ST benefits

Camil Parkhe
Saturday, 21 April 2018     goo.gl/eKp5u3  
By recommending minority status to the Lingayat community, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has indeed opened a Pandora’s box. With the move made prior to the declaration of the State assembly elections, he has scored a political point over the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Meanwhile, the issue of recognising Lingayat sect as an independent religion has been kept at an abeyance.  
By recommending minority status to the Lingayat community, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah has indeed opened a Pandora’s box. With the move made prior to the declaration of the State assembly elections, he has scored a political point over the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Meanwhile, the issue of recognising Lingayat sect as an independent religion has been kept at an abeyance.  
The issue of granting the status of an independent religion is not so complex. The Lingayat community has many sub-sects which include Scheduled Caste (SC) and Other Backward Class (OSC) sections. After securing recognition as an independent religion, it is feared that the SC and OBC members of the Lingayat community will be automatically deprived of the reservation and other benefits which are presently available to them. This was pointed out by the  Union ministry of home affairs in a reply to the Karnataka government. The fear of losing the benefits of the Scheduled Caste category deter some Lingayats from seeking separate religion status, but this is an only half truth. There are some precedents in the past 70 years which reveal that religion is not a barricade to deprive a community of its rightful Scheduled  Caste or Scheduled Tribe benefits.
The Constitution has provided for special benefits to the deprived sections of the society, referred to as Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, to compensate for their centuries old neglect. As per a Presidential order issued in 1949, only members of the Hindu religion were entitled to the Scheduled Castes status. However, the Scheduled Tribes (ST) status was also accorded to non-Hindus, to Christians as well, owing to the majority of the Christians in northeastern statues who belonged to various tribes.
The Presidential Order was amended in 1956 to accord the Scheduled Caste status to the erstwhile members of the untouchable communities or the Dalits in the Sikh religion. Incidentally, Punjab has a large percentage of Dalits who are part of Sikhism.
Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar embraced Buddhism along with lakhs of his followers in Nagpur in 1956. There was the possibility of these Dalits losing their Scheduled Caste benefits after moving out of the Hindu religion’s fold. In his historic address after the mass conversion ceremony, the architect of the Indian Constitution had vowed to ensure that the Dalits embracing Buddhism would not lose their benefits granted by the Constitution. Unfortunately, Dr Ambedkar died within a couple of months after the mass conversion. Hindu Dalits who became Buddhists were not eligible to avail of the benefits granted by the Constitution prior to their conversion. This anomaly was removed three decades later by the Janata Dal government led by Prime Minister Vishwanath Pratap Singh in 1990.
This shows that SC and OBC members of the Lingayat community would not forfeit their claim over the reservation benefits if Lingayat is treated as an independent religion. There are also other sections of society who are demanding Scheduled Caste benefits, these are Dalits who have embraced Christianity during the past few centuries. 
Dalit Christians are demanding that like Hindu Dalits, Sikh Dalits and Buddhist Dalits, they should also be given benefits of the SC reservation facility. The national parties have never perceived the Christians as a vote bank and hence, the issue has never been considered sympathetically. This is not the case with the Lingayat community which has a sizeable presence in Karnataka and Maharashtra. The parties eyeing power in these states or at the Centre can ill-afford to ignore the demands of  Lingayats for an independent religion.  

Tags

Karnataka Siddaramaiah Bharatiya Janata Party Scheduled Caste Reservation Ministry Of Home Affairs Lingayats Scheduled Tribe Constitution Scheduled Castes Dalit Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Nagpur Prime Minister Vote Bank Maharashtra

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dnyanodaya monthly enters 175th year

Image
Dnyanodaya monthly enters 175th year CAMIL PARKHE |  Wednesday, 31 May 2017 AT 11:10 PM IST          goo.gl/t2mMQq    Camil Parkhe ,  Dnyanodaya Pune:  Dnyanodaya monthly, founded and edited by American missionaries for many decades, has earned the distinction of being the longest surviving Marathi periodical. The monthly is celebrating its 175th year here on Saturday, June 3. Dnanodaya fortnightly was founded by the American Marathi Mission’s clergy in Ahmednagar by Rev Henry Balentine, a scholar in Greek, Latin, Sanskrit and Marathi languages, on June 20, 1842. The fortnightly was later converted into a monthly. Presently, it is published from the city and is edited by Ashok Angre. Balentine edited the periodical from 1842 to 1845 and again from 1858 to 1865. The other American missionaries who edited the Marathi periodical for many years included Robert Wilson Hume, Dr Samuel Fairback, Dr Allen Hazen, Charles Park, Ed...
Read more

Shakuntala Paranjape : Crusade of a lifetime

Shakuntala Paranjape :  Crusade of a lifetime Pune Plus The Times of India By Camil Parkhe When the list of recipients of national civilian awards was announced on the eve of Republic Day this year, the inclusion of her name among the Padma Bhushan awardees did not strike a loud note. Ironically, some newspapers in Pune, where she has worked as a lone crusader in the field of family planning, did not have a story on her. She was clubbed together with other eminent local persons who were also honoured with civilian awards. Perhaps there was a reason for this omission. The redoubtable Mrs. Shakuntala Paranjape, has been away from the limelight for more than two decades now. To Shakuntala Paranjape, who turned 85 on January 17, goes the credit of launching a long crusade for popularising family planning during the pre-independent era, when even discussing this issue in public was taboo. Many an eye-brow was raised when this lady, from a well-known and respected fami...
Read more

Fr. Rudolf Schoch. A Jesuit Looks back in satisfaction

Fr. Rudolf Schoch. Looking back in satisfaction Pune Plus, The Times of India (1991) By Camil Parkhe From days in the forties and fifties when he went horseback to visit the Jesuits-run 50 schools in Ahmednagar district to his present retirement days in Pune, it has been a period of great challenge and fulfillment for Fr. Rudolf Schoch. The founder of two reputed schools in state, and school principal for 38 years, Fr. Schoch has set a record of a sorts which may shared by only a few. By a strange twist of history, this Swiss-born Jesuit had to choose India as his Karmabhoomi and later, in a similar manner, education as his mission in life. But Fr. Schoch, now 78, says that he has not regretted the two sudden changes In his career which moulded his life in an unexpected way. As the founder of Loyola High School in Pune and Dnyanamata High School in Sangamner in Ahmednagar district and as an able administrator, Fr. Schoch commands respect in academic circles. But that is ...
Read more